Why These Myths Persist — and Why They Matter
Standardized tests occupy an outsized place in the college-application anxiety landscape. From the SAT and ACT to AP and IB exams, scores feel high-stakes — and where stakes feel high, myths tend to multiply. Families often receive conflicting information from well-meaning school counselors, online forums, and older relatives whose experience reflects a very different admissions era.
Clearing up these misconceptions isn't just an academic exercise. Acting on faulty assumptions can lead students to over-test, skip preparation that would actually help, or misread a school's policy in ways that affect their application strategy. Understanding what the evidence actually says helps families make calmer, more informed decisions. For a broader look at how assessments work before students even reach high school, see our guide to standardized tests in grades K–8.
Myth
If a college is test-optional, submitting a score doesn't really matter — they won't look at it.
Fact
Test-optional means students may choose whether to submit scores. If a student does submit them, admissions readers generally do consider them alongside other application materials.
"Test-optional" refers to the submission policy, not how scores are weighted once received. Students who choose to submit a strong score may gain a meaningful advantage, while those with scores below a school's typical range may be better served withholding them. Some schools also distinguish between test-optional and test-blind policies — at truly test-blind institutions, scores are never reviewed regardless of submission. Families should read each school's policy carefully, since the terms are not interchangeable.
Myth
Retaking the SAT or ACT always leads to a higher score, so students should keep testing.
Fact
Score improvements on a retake are common but not guaranteed, and significant gains typically require deliberate preparation between attempts.
Research from College Board and ACT, Inc. shows that many students do see modest score increases on a second attempt, partly because of familiarity with the test format. However, students who retake without additional preparation often see minimal or no improvement — and in some cases scores dip slightly. A third or fourth retake yields diminishing returns for most students. The more productive approach is identifying specific skill gaps after a first attempt and addressing them systematically before retesting.
Myth
A high SAT or ACT score proves a student is smart, while a low score means they're not college material.
Fact
Standardized tests measure a defined set of academic skills — primarily reading comprehension, math reasoning, and writing — not general intelligence or overall academic promise.
Both tests were designed to assess readiness for college-level coursework in specific domains, not to evaluate creativity, perseverance, leadership, or the full range of intellectual ability. Many colleges treat scores as one data point within a much broader application context. Students who struggle with timed, multiple-choice formats may still thrive in college environments that reward discussion, project-based learning, or research. Conversely, a very high score doesn't guarantee academic success if other foundational habits aren't in place.
Myth
Superscoring means every college combines your best section scores from multiple test dates.
Fact
Superscoring policies differ significantly from school to school — and some colleges do not superscore at all.
Superscoring refers to the practice of combining a student's best section scores across multiple test sittings to produce the highest composite. For example, a college that superscores the SAT might take your best Evidence-Based Reading and Writing score from one date and your best Math score from another. However, not every institution does this, and some superscore the SAT but not the ACT, or vice versa. Before planning a multi-date testing strategy, families should verify each target school's policy directly on its admissions website.
Myth
Expensive test prep courses guarantee a dramatic score increase.
Fact
Prep courses can improve familiarity and reduce test anxiety, but the evidence for large, consistent score gains across all students is mixed.
Structured test prep — whether through a course, a tutor, or self-guided practice — does help many students, primarily by building familiarity with question types and pacing strategies. However, gains vary considerably based on a student's starting point, the quality of the program, and how consistently they engage with practice materials. Independent research has generally found more modest average improvements than are sometimes advertised. Free and low-cost resources, including official practice tests from College Board and ACT, Inc., provide the same question formats used on actual exams and can be highly effective when used with discipline.
Myth
Standardized test scores are the most important factor in college admissions.
Fact
At most selective colleges, test scores are one component among many — grades, course rigor, essays, and recommendations often carry equal or greater weight.
Admissions surveys and published research consistently show that high school GPA and the rigor of a student's coursework rank among the top factors considered. Essays, letters of recommendation, extracurricular involvement, and demonstrated interest also play meaningful roles at many institutions. The relative weight of test scores has shifted further following the widespread expansion of test-optional policies. Families can be reassured that a single test number rarely determines an outcome on its own.
Putting Test Scores in the Right Context
Even after debunking individual myths, one larger misconception often lingers: that test scores exist in isolation. In reality, a score only becomes meaningful when placed alongside the full picture of a student's academic record, interests, and goals.
75%+
4-year colleges with test-optional or test-flexible policies
As of the early 2020s, FairTest reported that the majority of U.S. bachelor's-degree-granting institutions had adopted some form of test-optional or test-flexible admissions.
~20–30 pts
Typical SAT score increase after one retake
College Board data has indicated that students who retake the SAT without additional preparation tend to see modest average composite gains, often in the 20–30 point range.
#1
Factor most colleges cite as most important
NACAC's State of College Admission reports have consistently found high school GPA and course rigor ranked above test scores as the leading admissions factors at most institutions surveyed.
For families also weighing the financial side of college decisions, it's worth noting that test scores can sometimes influence merit aid eligibility — another reason to understand how each school uses them. Our article on misreading financial aid award letters explains how offer letters can obscure the true cost of attendance. Similarly, families navigating gifted-program testing will find familiar myth-busting territory in our piece on common myths about gifted education.
Policy Details Change — Always Verify Directly
Test-optional, test-blind, and superscoring policies are not permanent and can shift from one admissions cycle to the next. What a school practiced during the pandemic may not reflect its current requirements. Always check each college's official admissions page for the most current information before making decisions about testing strategy.
The most grounded approach treats standardized testing as a single, manageable step in a longer process — one that rewards preparation and clear-eyed expectations over worry and guesswork.
This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. Admissions policies vary by institution and change over time; always verify current requirements directly with each school's admissions office.
The content provided on our blog site traverses numerous categories, offering readers valuable and practical information. Readers can use the editorial team’s research and data to gain more insights into their topics of interest. However, they are requested not to treat the articles as conclusive. The website team cannot be held responsible for differences in data or inaccuracies found across other platforms. Please also note that the site might also miss out on various schemes and offers available that the readers may find more beneficial than the ones we cover.